Systematic Dialectics on Redblades Anabaptist Church

Contra Constantinian Protestantism

Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000

Written for the Protestant reader

We are not opponents of the Reformation's central discovery, of the conviction that Scripture stands over every human institution, or of the evangelical's hard-won insistence that religion is a matter of the heart and not merely of inherited form. We are diagnosing why a Reformation that got the theology right has spent five centuries failing to build what that theology requires. The Architectonic is Protestant through and through, standing in the specific lineage of the Radical Reformation. This is the case that Protestantism, everywhere it did not become Anabaptist, has never finished the work it started.

Contra Eastern Orthodox

Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000

Written for the Eastern Orthodox reader

Eastern Orthodoxy is the most intellectually serious competitor the Redblades Architectonic faces. Not Catholicism — which shares Orthodoxy's structural deficiency but has less sophisticated philosophical armature. Not secular liberalism — which collapses too quickly under BTO's eliminative pressure. This document is written in the spirit of the highest compliment one intellectual can pay another: total honesty.

Three Concessions — Before We Begin

One: Unconditional Eternal Security (OSAS) is false. The New Testament teaches Conditional Preservation. The Architectonic's TAAS theology agrees with Eastern Orthodoxy completely on this point.

Two: The Magisterial Reformers made catastrophic errors. Calvin had Servetus burned. Luther had Anabaptists killed. The Constantinian settlement they retained produced Enlightenment liberalism. We agree with the Orthodox critique of them.

Three: Generic tradition without a specific living community is useless. We are not defending abstract Protestant principles. We are defending a specific, historically-grounded tradition with 500 years of community life — the Anabaptist covenant community — and a complete theory of reality derived from first principles.

Part I: The First-Principles Grid

Eight fields of structural comparison. For the complete analysis, download the full document.

Contra Roman Catholicism

Mon, 01 Jan 0001 00:00:00 +0000

Written for the Traditionalist Catholic reader

We are not opponents of the Scholastic achievement, of the Roman liturgical inheritance, or of the intellectual seriousness of the Traditionalist Catholic who has looked honestly at the wreckage of the post-conciliar Church and refused to look away. We are opponents of specific metaphysical and institutional commitments that generate demonstrable incoherence — incoherence that, left unremedied, produces the very collapse the Traditionalist Catholic already mourns. This document is written in the spirit of the highest compliment one intellectual can pay another: total honesty.